@LiberalLibrarian Depends on the whiskey. American I like on the rocks (though sometimes neat). Irish, neat, or maybe with just a fleck of ice.
@LiberalLibrarian I hardly ever drink Scotch. Nothing against it, just prefer American & Irish. (Irish not very often, just when I want something sweet.)
The one that absolutely requires ice, for me, is vodka. And don't bother me with that Stoli or whatever nonsense -- I like real potato vodka. I want to taste those spuds, skins and all.