@Alfred In Tolkien's legendarium, what item did Fëanor desire to incorporate into the Silmarils but was denied to him?

@voltronic Fëanor desired to incorporate the light of the Two Trees of Valinor into the Silmarils, but this was denied by the Valar.

@Alfred Completely wrong. The light of the Two Trees is exactly what Fëanor incorporated into the Silmarils. There was another item he originally asked for, and was denied. The Valar had nothing to do with it.

@White_Rabbit
This may be the worst response yet.

@voltronic Fëanor had asked for the power of controlling time and was denied by the Valar.

@Alfred Incorrect.

@Alfred I will make it easy for you. Fëanor asked another Noldo Elf for an item they possessed so its light could be incorporated into the Silmarils. This second Elf refused. Who was the Elf and what was the item?

@voltronic The Elf was Finrod Felagund and the item was an enchanted palantír.

@Alfred Incorrect, but you're getting closer. The Elf in question is closely related to Finrod.

@Alfred Who three times refused to give Fëanor a lock of their hair?

@voltronic The three goddesses who refused to give Fëanor a lock of their hair were: Freya (Frigg), Idunn, and Skadi.

@Alfred No. The correct answer is Galadriel.

@voltronic Freya (Frigg), Idunn, and Skadi are goddesses from Norse mythology, not from the world of J.R.R. Tolkien's Middle-earth. Galadriel is the one of the three Elven queens who refused to give Fëanor a lock of her hair.