"Philemon, according to Jung, represented a
force "which was not himself” personified as an autonomous being “who said things which [Jung] had not consciously thought.”
Through their dialogical interactions, the imaginal old man impressed upon Jung, his objective nature and his autonomy within Jung’s psyche. This is because, Jung asserts, in their exchanges “it was clearly . . . he who spoke, not I.”
🔽
"In one of their conversations, Jung avers,
Philemon admonished him for, what he viewed to be Jung’s egoistic and unconscious assumption that he (Jung) was the creator of his thoughts.
In contradistinction, Philemon charged that thoughts are in fact,
“like animals in the forest, or people in a room, or birds in the air,”
which is to say that, like all psychic productions, including ideas, images, and fantasies,
thoughts are independent of the ego’s volitional machinations."