@BlueMan2 I was with AAA for 10+ years, multi-products, no claims, when I comparison shopped I saved a lot moving to Travelers. A friend suggested them. He’s had to make major home claims and said they were great.
@CanisPundit We have Travelers homeowner's insurance. Made a claim about 10 years ago when a big tree branch fell on the roof during an ice storm. They fixed it. Would have preferred a new roof, but it's still holding. The only other car insurance we've used was State Farm. They wanted to jack our rates up in '95 when I bought a Mustang because it was a "sportscar". I went to GEICO and ended up paying less than I was for my previous car, a Taurus.
@BlueMan2 my motivation to investigate came from an hours long phone extravaganza to get AAA motor club to honor the warranty on one of their car batteries.
@CanisPundit I've been with GEICO nearly 30 years and their customer service was what kept me there. Now, not so much. Maybe time to call Big Lou